Comparing Air Source and Ground Source Heat Pumps: Which is Right for You?

Comparing Air Source and Ground Source Heat Pumps: Which is Right for You?

Heat pumps have become a game-changer in home heating and cooling, offering an energy-efficient alternative to traditional systems. But if you're considering one, you’ve probably come across the two main types: air source heat pumps (ASHPs) and ground source heat pumps (GSHPs). Each has its strengths, weaknesses, and ideal use cases. So, how do you decide which is best for your home?

Let’s break it down.

How Heat Pumps Work

Before diving into the comparison, it’s helpful to understand the basic concept. A heat pump doesn’t create heat like a furnace. Instead, it transfers heat from one place to another. Either from the air or the ground into your home (or vice versa for cooling). This process significantly reduces energy consumption compared to traditional heating methods.

Now, let’s weigh the options.

What Is an Air Source Heat Pump?

Air source heat pumps extract heat from the outside air, even in cold temperatures, and transfer it into your home. They operate much like an air conditioner in reverse during winter but can also cool your home in summer.

Pros of Air Source Heat Pumps

  • Lower Initial Cost - Compared to GSHPs, ASHPs are more budget-friendly upfront.
  • Easier Installation - No need to dig trenches or install underground piping.
  • Compact Size - Generally takes up less space and is easier to fit in urban or smaller properties.
  • Efficient for Moderate Climates - Performs well in areas where winters don’t get extremely harsh.

Cons of Air Source Heat Pumps

  • Less Efficient in Extreme Cold - When temperatures drop significantly, efficiency can decline.
  • Shorter Lifespan Compared to GSHPs - Typically lasts 10-15 years, whereas a GSHP can last up to 25 years.
  • Noise Factor - Some models generate noticeable outdoor noise, which might be a concern for noise-sensitive homeowners.

What About Ground Source Heat Pumps?

Ground source heat pumps, also known as geothermal heat pumps, use underground loops to extract heat from the soil, where temperatures remain relatively stable year-round.

Pros of Ground Source Heat Pumps

  • Higher Energy Efficiency - Because ground temperatures remain stable, GSHPs can maintain high efficiency, even in extreme cold.
  • Longer Lifespan - The underground components can last 50+ years, while indoor units typically last around 20-25 years.
  • Lower Operating Costs - Higher efficiency means lower energy bills in the long run.
  • Quieter Operation - Since most components are underground, GSHPs tend to be quieter than ASHPs.

Cons of Ground Source Heat Pumps

  • Expensive Upfront Cost - Installation costs are significantly higher due to excavation or drilling.
  • Complicated Installation Process - Requires adequate land space for horizontal loops or drilling for vertical loops.
  • Longer Payback Period - While you save on energy bills, it can take years to recoup the initial investment.

Key Factors to Consider

Now that we’ve laid out the basics, how do you decide between the two? Consider these factors:

1. Your Budget

If you're working with a tighter budget, an air source heat pump is more accessible due to its lower upfront cost. However, if you’re looking for long-term savings and can handle the initial investment, a ground source heat pump could be the better financial decision.

2. Local Climate

Colder regions may see better efficiency from a ground source heat pump, while air source systems work well in milder climates. Some newer ASHP models are designed to handle extreme cold, but they may require a backup heating system.

3. Available Space

If you don’t have much land, installing a GSHP might not be feasible unless you opt for a vertical loop system, which requires deeper, more expensive drilling. On the other hand, an air source unit simply needs space for an outdoor unit.

4. Long-Term Savings vs Short-Term Costs

Think about your long-term plans. If you plan to stay in the same home for decades, a GSHP might be worth the investment. If you’re unsure about long-term plans, an ASHP could be the more practical choice.

Real-World Perspective

I’ve seen homeowners make both choices successfully. A neighbour of mine installed a GSHP about ten years ago, and while the installation was quite the ordeal. With drilling and landscaping work. It paid off. Their energy bills dropped significantly compared to neighbours with gas or electric heating.

On the other hand, another friend opted for an ASHP in a suburban home. They prioritized ease of installation and a lower upfront price. While they do see some loss in efficiency during particularly cold spells, the system has worked well overall.

Final Thoughts

Both air source and ground source heat pumps offer impressive energy-efficient heating and cooling. The right choice depends on your budget, climate, available space, and long-term plans.

If affordability and ease of installation matter most, an air source heat pump might be your winner. If energy efficiency and long-term savings are your top concerns. And you’re willing to invest upfront. A ground source system could be the way to go.

Thinking about making the switch? Research local incentives and speak with heat pump installers in your area to get a clearer picture of what would work best for your home.

Back to blog